Pride of America receives mixed reviews, with many guests praising the ship's itinerary and staff friendliness, but others noting issues with food quality, entertainment, and value for money. The cruise is widely regarded as an excellent way to see the Hawaiian Islands, but service inconsistencies, understaffing, and aging ship facilities are recurring concerns. Specialty dining and excursions are often highlighted positively, while main dining and entertainment options receive more criticism. Pricing and extra charges are a common complaint. Overall, the cruise is recommended for the unique itinerary, but expectations should be managed regarding ship amenities and services.